Enrico’s Pizza

Service was great, food was hot and fresh. We got there a little late at 8:40pm but were not rushed. The truffle fries were amazing! This place does not disappoint!!

I don’t know why I keep giving this place a chance. Tonight we picked up a pizza, a salad, and 6 hot buffalo wings. Our total was $70! The wings were barely edible and naked! The pizza was okay but super expensive. The Enrico’s salad was a very small portion size and the red wine vinaigrette was just red wine vinegar. The pickup service was so awkward. I asked multiple times (on the phone and at the counter) for an extra side of ranch. The young man at the cash register could not comprehend what I was asking. After consuming the food we instantly had stomach pain and multiple trips to the bathroom. Overall, not worth the money!

Enrico's pizza was pretty good, better than I thought it would be for it being in the keys. The pizza was cooked well done as asked for. The pizza was cheesy, and there were plenty of ingredients on the pizza just like we asked for. The crust on it was delicious and crunchy and very addictive. We also ordered enricos salad, and it too was delicious, very well served, and hearty.

Enrico’s Meatball and Ricotta pizza was fantastic. Just a quick ride from our rental condo to pick it up hot and fresh. The crust is crisp and fresh. We loved it so much we came back a few days later for the exact same thing. Don’t forget to grab some grated Parmesan and crushed red pepper packets, paper plates, napkins and plastic ware at the front. Friendly staff, tip well, and refer a friend!

Highly recommended!!! We stopped by on our way from Key West to Key Largo. The food is really good, the tomato sauce used in the pizza is delicious! Great quality, generous portions and very reasonably priced. The service is top tier ✅ unlike any other pizzeria i have ever been. Thanks again Laura & Felipe. Keep up the great work 💪🏼

I have always passed Enrico's heading in and out of the Keys. I decided to finally stop with 10 hungry teenagers and so happy I did! Not only was the food great, the service was great also. Very friendly and very welcoming. The indoor decor is super cool with photos and memorabilia of the Bronx and the movie Rocky. We ordered a wide variety of food. Pasta, pizza, subs, salad and everything was delish! Definitely going back!

Popular place we are told. Good pizza. Okay flavor, definitely had better. Took awhile to get our food and last dish didn't come out until after the rest of us finished. And we had to ask if our food was ready, so it was no longer hot when we got it. We were the only customers there. Very casual atmosphere. Update: enjoyed the key lime pie. I'm on a quest to find the best one. The one is the only one with a unique crust with pecan. It is drizzled with carmel. The lime is nice and tart. I think the carmel adds a nice balance but could cut the amount in half so it's not so sweet altogether. The texture is a smooth and heavy. Portion size is a 1/4 pie so it's good for two but I ate the whole thing myself. At this point it's my favorite in the Keys.

4.5 stars. While in Islamorada, get over to Enrico's. Their pizza is very good! Its a New York style pizza. This is the best pizza in the Keys that I've had. Great crust and light on the sauce with very good cheese and toppings. If anything, get the pizza! But they also offer great pasta dishes as well. This time, we tried the Linguine and Clams and the Shrimp Ala Enrico. Both were very good. Great sauce. The clams were nice and very good. The shrimp was tasty. The only reason I gave 4.5 stars is because our meals were served with spaghetti noodles and not linguine. I was looking forward to the linguine, but the spaghetti noodles were very good. We sat outside where there is plenty of seating and it was clean on the inside. The service was great as well. I will be returning to try other items on the menu. Thanks for a great experience!